SeeD419's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Forest fires]

lol

Pretty awesome, not very long, but at least functional and humorous. I honestly didn't see that coming, so I got a laugh out of it. The drawings are decent and the animation looks really good. Seems smooth.

I suppose you could have improved the drawings a bit, and since it's so short I really can't rate it much higher, but for what it's worth I enjoyed it.

Keep up the good work.

[Turkey Day Follies]

lolol

Well, I found it to be slightly amusing. It was a good idea for a flash short and I think you executed it well, in my opinion.

The drawings were good, and the animation wasn't top notch, but it definitely got the job done. I think you could have done a bit better on the facial expressions and syncing to the laughing, but it wasn't bad. Most of the animation had a good style to it and looked good.

The leaves at the beginning were a nice touch and the background looked good. The humorous touch with the cow's ghost at the end holding the sign was quite funny - that and the fact that the guy and the chicken were eating burgers, lol.

Not a bad little thanksgiving animation, just submitted a tad bit late ;) Keep up the great work though.

-RRC-

[The Green Line Collab]

Good work

Certainly a lot of work in here, a submission totally worthy of submitting :D

The idea of a green line connecting all the works is interesting, regardless of if it's been done before or not. I think you executed the idea really well, and all the pieces seem to flow at least somewhat decent. I think you could have made them feel more connected, but nonetheless it was done well.

The opening song is one of my favorite daft punk songs, lol. Love that, and the music throughout the collab seemed to fit the fast pace of it well. Not to mention it was timed perfectly with the end of the artwork. I will admit I was impressed. I did wish that the art hadn't moved so quickly though. I didn't feel like pausing the screen nonstop but if it had moved a little bit slower it would have been easier to really appreciate each individual piece.

The menu was well thought out as well as the animated credits and then scrolling movie credits. All of those were nice touches that make this have the 'dvd' feel to it and makes it look a lot more professional.

Overall a great collab. Every artist in this should be proud to be featured in it.

[Rotoscope Compilation!]

Not bad

Well, you're the ones who took the class, so you all would obviously know a lot more about this kind of film editing or animation style than I do. The clips are semi-interesting to watch, but not really overly entertaining. Most of them were dancing, which is kinda cool, but not really anything interesting to watch by itself.

It kinda felt like right as the clip was about to be something worth watching that they cut off. I'm assuming this is due to the fact that these were all just assignments for a class and not meant to be something for public entertainment. I mean...it's obvious that you're all doing well in the class and learning things, but as a collab of all of your finished assignments it really isn't anything I'd want to watch again.

Overall a good collab of your work in school, but little value for public entertainment if you ask me - due to a lack of any real plot or humor. Keep up the good work though.

akoRn responds:

thanks.. this juz to practice the rotoscope technique. so no real plot is needed, but that juz our opinion anyway.

thx for the vote , 7-ed n review

[Cast Away]

Umm

I'm not voting zero on this because I'm 'superficial and don't actually look at content." Yes, I will admit that the drawings are probably the worst I've seen in a long time. On top of that, the animation is nothing short of atrocious - it isn't even synced properly. That's not the point though...

Your 'content' is a failed attempt to parody cast away that isn't in any way even remotely funny. Matches? He was stranded on an island in the middle of nowhere...of course he didn't have any matches. You could have said the same thing about a lighter, or a gas stove, it wouldn't matter because he was on an island. He was happy to have made fire from scratch without any of these modern conveniences, and your joke honestly makes no sense at all. There's no clever humor what-so-ever, so I'm not being superficial here, this just honestly sucks and totally deserves to be blammed.

Darwin7 responds:

It wasn't intended to parody Cast Away and my characters aren't on an island. The name is purely coincidental.

[WH40K: SpaceHulk]

Awesome

Well, the drawings are certainly fantastic, and the animation looks good. The movie is nice and lengthy...errm...well that just sounds wrong but you know what I mean.

Most of the dialogue is funny and entertaining. I like how you gave different characters distinguishable voices, like the stuttering guy. I do think you could have done a better job with the recording of the voice acting though....sounded like a bad mic or something...quality wasn't as good as it could have been.

Other than the quality of sound clips, the other sounds were all appropriate and fit in well. The WTF bomb was a bit random, but I guess the whole concept seemed a bit random to me so it worked. Not a bad movie at all, I can't wait to see the next installment. Keep up the great work.

[There She Is!! final step]

Wow

Well I'm not much for Asian culture...not to say I'm against it or anything, it just doesn't really interest me. Your flash skills here are nothing short of amazing, which is why this is on the top 50, and why it's BEEN on the top 50 for so long. The animation is flawless. I honestly can't find a whole in it, and the story feels very complete. It has an intro, a climax, and an outro - as it should, and it feels very fitting.

The drawings are all good, nothing absolutely insane, but they look great and they keep the theme from the others in the series. I think it's been about 5 years since I last saw one of these episodes, lol. I can't believe I never reviewed this one.

The music isn't bad really. No clue what the lyrics are, but it fits the animation perfectly.

Keep up the amazing work.

[Dance of the Manwhore]

lol

It's pretty good, and loops amazingly. The song is actually kinda catchy and the electronic beat is great. The lyrics are obviously really strange, but they go amazingly with the flash animation.

The drawings are really good, above average I'd say, although I still see room for improvement on some parts. Most of the drawings were very good though. The lip syncing is a bit off, not from the audio but just not as accurate as it could be in my opinion.

Overall I'd say the song you made really completes this. The animation is obviously very good, but I wouldn't say a 10/10. Keep up the great work.

[Thanksgiving Massacre]

Wow

I must say I'm thoroughly impressed with this animation. The sounds and music were all perfect and the drawings were great. The animation is just about flawless and the concept is hilarious.

I suppose as far as things to improve on, just add more color. A lot of the backgrounds seemed really bland and grayscale. Keep up the good work, nonetheless, loved this.

Rapheus responds:

It seems that each of my 'Madness' flashes keep getting more colorful. Come back in five years and they should be in full color. ;P

[Obnoxious Octopus [HD]]

lol

Well the remastered version is certainly a lot better than the other one. I can tell you redid the drawings a lot better, the voice syncing almost looks believeable, and the whole presentation is much better. Good work, keep making these they're fuckin funny, lol.