SeeD419's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Incompetent Chivalry]

Genius

LOL! That was great! Halarious!

Graphics (8) - Pretty good for hand drawn. I could tell you did most of this frame by frame, must have been a bitch but hey, its worth it right? Nice finished product!

Style (10) - Never seen anything like it. I really like your style.

Sound (8) - A couple sounds/voices were pretty annoying but great job overall.

Violence (8) - Pretty violent scenes at times, loved it.

Interactivity (1) - It had a play button, and a replay button, but since I started using overall as an average, this brought it from an 8.6 to a 7.3

Humor (9) - LOL! Loved your sense of humor!

=============================

Overall (7.3) - Loved the movie, great sense of humor too! Graphics were awesome because the whole time you're thinking, "Wow, look at this frame by frame animation here." Make more! LoL. This was an excellent piece of work. Keep it up man!

[Alfred Pokingstick]

Wow

Nice man!

Graphics (10) - Unbelieveable! I Couldn't believe what I was watching wasn't an actual movie!

Style (10) - Very original, awesome animation style too.

Sound (8) - LOL! Kung-fu fighting?? Nice sound. Very funny songs!

Violence (6) - Christ, once it started it didn't stop!

Interactivity (3) - Nice little selection screen, I'll give you 3 for it.

Humor (8) - Well it's definately funny, need I say more?

Overall (9) - Although it lacks a point in every way, shape, and form, I still loved it. Nicely done man, keep up the good work!

[Litter Bug]

Pretty funny

I liked it. *Sigh* Here we go:

Graphics (10) - Haven't given a 10 on graphics in quite a while, you should be honored. Very well drawn. In fact, exceptionally well drawn. These almost seemed unreal.

Style (10) - Loved the style to the whole thing. Your animation style was awesome, as well as your drawing style.

Sound (6) - Christ, this was the only problem it had. The sound was terrible at some points and annoying at others. I'd seriously consider re-recording that, then this would be perfect.

Violence & Interactivity (0) - Who didn't see that comin?

Humor (8) - Pretty damn funny man, I like your humor

Overall (8) - If it wasn't for that damn sound, this would have been so awesome. Ah, who cares? You can easily re-record it. Problem is, I wouldn't be able to re-review it, so if you do, make the 8 a 9 for me. K? Thx!

[HENTAI HOTNESS]

Why?

I agree with the guy before me completely. He's abolutely right, lol. Why do the turds always have to do with Hentai recently? Why the hell would you just put that huge song file in there? For graphics you get a 7, it wasn't THAT bad. I've definately seen worse. For sound you get a 6, although the song pissed me off because it took like 2 minutes to load. For everything else you get a zero, and that's how it should be. You had no style in this whatsoever, no violence, no interactivity, and no humor. It was pretty pointless to watch. Some of the turds I could actually watch and get into to an extent, but this was beyond terrible. I know you can do better than this, I've seen your other animations, fourstar. Why you did this is beyond me. Oh yeah, this is ninestar by the way, from the forums. Too bad all my spam got deleted and I got banned :)

FourStar responds:

Thank you for your opinion regarding the movie.

[FOR EVERYONE]

Nice man

Really touching. This just goes to show you, it's not all humor and violence. We need some of this every once and a while, what was your inspiration for this piece?

For graphics you get an 8. I really liked your drawing style, pretty well done. I also liked how you animated the scene to have wind. Nobody can just stare at a motionless screen and you took that into account. For style you get a 10. Nobody does this and more people should. Your animation style was also awesome, as I already said. For sound I'm giving you an 8. The music went really well with this. Very touching throughout the whole thing. Keep up the good work man, I liked this. You've definately got talent, just put some more animation in there (not this one, it was fine) and you'll be a top-notch animator!

[-outpost part two-]

Awesome

Man, if this would have been any longer, you would have gotten a 10 from me, and I never give 10s. Your graphics kicked ass, it didn't matter that they were sticks. The sound was awesome, I loved listening to everything that was going on, no static or anything. For style you get a 10, I think this is a very well animated flash, and very original. For violence you get an 8, It wasn't exactly the goriest thing ever, but you had some fight scenes that I found pretty damn cool. For interactivity, I'll have to give you a six. I really didn't do much. This felt more like a movie than it did a game. Humor you get a 7, I thought it was pretty funny. Overall I'm giving you a 9. Could have definately been a 10 though if it was longer, yes I realize there is a part one but it still was pretty short. Really good job though, keep up the good work man!

[One Ring to Rule ThemAll3]

Umm?

I dunno man. You're a genius as far as animation goes. Your graphics are flawless but I guess there's a big difference in humor here. I honestly can't say I found most of this funny at all. The salad part at the movie theatre was pretty funny...for like a second. It's like my dad's humor...so It kinda got old for me, lol. I'm not going to downgrade you on it though, it seems most people found it funny so I really can't say you're not funny because of a difference of opinon. You know what, fuck it, I was writing this before it was over, it is pretty funny. I really enjoyed your movie. I found it pretty interesting! You had me glued!

[Foamy's Rant IV]

LOL OMG

Hahaha, illwillpress, I was an avid foamy hater but this is rigoddamndiculous! LOL! I think you've changed for the better with your past movies. I love it! Foamy's a genius, every word he says is true. I think I'm going to convert to foamyism, lol. Hell, it's better than being athiest at least...

[Super Mario GMA Ep.1]

Nicely done!

Wow, pretty cool man, considering it's mario. I'm not into the whole 'nintendo' thing persay, but I found this pretty interesting.

Graphics (8) - Well done, I don't think you need any improvement here, it's just not 'top of the line'

Style (9) - I like the way you did this, the only reason you get a 9 instead of a 10 is because it's Mario, it's not exactly 'original.'

Sound (6) - Excellent Mario remixes, I like those a lot. I'm downgrading you here only because it would kick so much more ass if you had voices! You also missed some vital sound effects, like bombs and such.

Violence (2) - Not a problem, it's Mario, not supposed to be real violent.

Interactivity (0) - No shit, it's a movie :P

Humor (2) - Not extremely funny, but I had a chuckle at a couple of the things...

Overall (7) - The movie's fine, all thats left is "extra" improvements. Things could make this a lot better, like weekly top 20 stuff.

[Gamer Elite: Episode 3]

Good lord...

That was really long man. Next time I'll cook a bag of popcorn and get a soda before I watch this, lol. Well, let's see here. Your graphics weren't the best, but they weren't bad either, you get a 7. I felt this was a pretty average score. For style you get a 10 definately. I don't know why I was glued to this movie, but I was. For sound, you get an 8. You had some pretty good music choices in there and some pretty interesting voices, some of them could use a little work though. For violence I gave you a 7. It's violent yet it's not. They're fighting but theres no blood or guts. I realize that its sonic though, so I didn't downgrade you because of it. I liked the fight scenes, myself. Interactivity, 0, as usual. And for humor I gave you a 6. I thought some parts of it were pretty comical. Overall I'd give you an 8. Good job on creating this really long decent movie/future sprite kinda thing. Keep up the good work!