SeeD419's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[Starcraft Terran Medic]

Jesus Christ

Probably one of the most amazing and realistic pieces of artwork I've ever seen.

Words fail me. You sir, are a true master at art.

[Starcraft Terran Ghost]

Amazing

Another just amazing piece of artwork.

I apologize but there's just nothing to critique at all. 10/10

[Girl in blue]

Oh...that's not a real picture of a girl?

Pretty impressive artwork here.

This is so beyond my personal abilities that I can't even begin to critique it. Just amazing work. Keep it up.

[Darth Vulgar]

Nice

Well, the Vader drawing itself is actually quite good. Quite frankly far better than I could ever do. The glare on the helmet and glove really add depth to the picture, or mainly the helmet really.

The background is pretty amateur. I could imagine myself drawing some I beams that looked similar, but the effort with the gradients is noted. The stars and space look could have also used improvements, but once again far better than anything I could ever draw.

Overall it's a good drawing. Not necessarily the greatest Vader drawing ever, but I could probably do far worse. Realistically, I'd probably give it a 7, but since you help run the website that created the art portal in which I type this very review, why not be generous and bump it up to an 8? I mean I do like that shiny helmet...

[Alien Muse]

Nice

Well the artwork is very good on this piece, although the colors are a bit strange.

The signature was certainly a nice touch and is interesting to look at.

The sky looks cool, and the mountains have style. The alien is rather strange but was depicted well.

Overall a rather strange image. Doesn't really convey any certain meaning to me personally, but the artwork is good nonetheless.

Keep up the good work

-RRC-

InsertFunnyUserName responds:

Thanks.

It's not meant to have meaning, really. It was created as a submission for the alien art collab.

[A fine light]

Better

Better, but still lacking. The colors are actually pleasing to look at in this one, however the art seems more lacking here. The other piece had a someone abstract theme going on, where as this one is like a sky just...distorted.

The clouds don't really come off as clouds and neither does the sun.

Not sure what else to say, this one just isn't doing it for me.

-RRC-

[the demons face]

Meh

I see what you were going for here, and I'm a fan of abstract so I can appreciate this. The main problem I see with this is total disregard for color theory.

The white bleeding through is the biggest downfall to the image in my opinion. The image is just too loud and lacks balance with the other bright colors and it's just overall eye rape.

I'd be willing to be if the white was black instead the image would be a lot better. I see the demonic face, but it's not significant enough to be really moving.

Keep at it, you'll get better.

-RRC-

[The Ozzman VS The Batman]

Nice

Pretty good image. The depiction of Ozzy looks pretty accurate and the 'bat' character he's biting looks good. Might have been cooler had it been a real bad, but w/e. The background is strange, but appropriate for the image.

Shading was done pretty well and the glasses have a nice glassy effect that works well. I also like the shine on the hair. Pretty convincing.

The hand is probably the most realistic looking part of the image. It was drawn incredibly well.

Overall a little mismatched and not a theme I really get into, but a good image nonetheless. Keep up the good work.

-RRC-

Merol responds:

You mean an actual bad character since Ozzy is not actually evil?

Thanks! I used my own hand as a reference.

THANKS A LOT!

[Pushing Onwards]

Not bad

The character was drawn very well, and the white outline was a nice effect. The background was certainly a nice touch to avoid it looking bland and without bearings.

The design is pretty good, and looks well suited for a comic. The proportion in some places is a tad questionable, but in a comic it would fit very well.

The shading is very good and the colors play nice with each other. Pretty pleasing to the eyes actually.

Overall a good piece. I'd love to see what you can do with it.

-RRC-

[Mr. Buisness man]

Not bad

Even though it's devoid of a background, the character was made quite well actually. The shading looks decent and adds nice depth to the business man. He doesn't really strike me as a business man though. For some reason it looks like he just woke up and he's in his pajamas or something.

The briefcase also doesn't look very proportionate in my opinion, or that's like the smallest briefcase ever. The facial expression is a bit odd, and could probably use some improvement, but overall it's an okay picture. It certainly looks like he's in motion which is neat.

Overall, it has a few flaws, but also some good parts. It's a decent image, but could use a bit of polishing. Keep up the good work.

-RRC-

StalkerGuy responds:

Alright, thanks!